I’ve finally chosen a template for the website. It came down to these 3:
Bloxy Two 0.9.8.1 by Stefan Kröber (Arcance)
Inanis Glass 1.3.5 by Inanis
Mysterio 1.3 by DewDrop
Mysterio (my favorite Spider-Man villain, coincidentally) was the winner. I will eventually be making color, font, etc, changes as I go, so the look of the website will constantly evolve in appearance during the process.